Skip to content

ANDRGROUND ENGINEERINGREGISTERED ALBERTA TRADE NAME TN28292449WORK SEALED BY ANDREW RICHARDSON, P.ENG.

Larger and multi unit developments

Commercial and multi unit investigation

Deeper, denser subsurface work for buildings and sites whose loads, footprints and stormwater demands go well past what a single-family lot ever asks of the ground.

What this is

The work, and what it answers

A commercial building, a townhome block or an apartment does not just weigh more than a house. It concentrates that weight onto fewer, heavier columns, spreads a larger footprint across more of the site's natural variability, and usually arrives with a stormwater pond, deeper services and staged earthworks attached. Each of those is a place where the ground can decide the design. The investigation has to be built to answer them before the structural engineer sets column loads and before the pond is graded.

This page describes what a commercial or multi-unit geotechnical investigation adds on top of the residential and foundation work described earlier in this series: boreholes that go deeper and are spread more thickly across the site, settlement analysis carried out for the actual loads rather than assumed, geotechnical input on the stormwater or detention pond, and a clear, defensible answer to the question that drives the whole foundation budget: shallow footings, or piles?

Andrground Engineering serves southern and central Alberta. Every borehole is logged, every sample tested, and every recommendation analysed and sealed by a Professional Engineer registered with APEGA. Where a code or standard governs a decision, it is named and linked rather than left to be taken on trust.

Method

Where commercial work goes further than a house

On a single lot, a couple of boreholes to modest depth usually captures everything a light residential footing needs to know. A commercial or multi-unit site breaks both of those assumptions. The loads reach deeper into the ground, so the boreholes have to follow them past the depth where the stress from the building still matters (commonly well below footing level, scaled to the loaded width). And the footprint is larger, so a handful of holes no longer proves the ground is uniform beneath every part of it.

So a commercial investigation typically means more boreholes, spaced across the building footprint and the pond and pavement areas, and drilled deeper than residential practice, with the number and depth set by the loads, the footprint and the variability found rather than by a fixed recipe. The governing references are the National Building Code (2023 Alberta Edition), the Canadian Foundation Engineering Manual, and, for public and infrastructure work, the provincial Geotechnical Investigation Guidelines for Alberta Infrastructure Projects. Every hole is located and cleared through Utility Safety Partners before drilling, and the excavations and test pits are worked to Alberta OHS Code Part 32.

  • Depth follows the load: boreholes are advanced past the depth where the added stress from the structure is still significant, not stopped at footing level
  • Coverage follows the footprint: holes are spread so no large part of the building, pond or pavement is left unproven
  • Testing follows the question: SPT N-values and split-spoon samples for strength and profile, plus thin-wall (Shelby) tube samples where undisturbed clay is needed for settlement testing

Settlement analysis for larger loads

For a light house on firm ground, bearing capacity (the load at which the soil would fail in shear) is usually the whole story. For heavier, wider commercial loads on Alberta's clays and clay tills, settlement is often the real limit long before shear failure is a concern. A wide, heavily loaded footing pushes stress much deeper into the ground than a narrow one, and if a compressible clay lies within that influence zone it will consolidate and the building will settle.

What matters to the structure is not just how much it settles but how unevenly: differential settlement between columns is what cracks slabs, jams doors and distresses cladding. So where cohesive soils control, undisturbed samples are recovered and one-dimensional consolidation testing (ASTM D2435) is run, and Andrew Richardson, P.Eng. estimates both total and differential settlement for the actual proposed loads. The allowable bearing pressure he hands to the structural engineer is then the one that keeps settlement within tolerance, which is frequently lower than the value shear failure alone would allow.

  • Total and differential settlement estimated for the real column and floor loads, not a generic assumption
  • Consolidation (oedometer) testing on undisturbed clay where compressible layers sit within the load's influence depth
  • Allowable bearing set by settlement tolerance, not just factored bearing capacity, and stated as such

Stormwater and detention-pond geotechnical assessment

Most larger developments have to hold back their own stormwater, which means a detention or retention pond, an engineered wetland, or buried storage. A pond is a geotechnical structure in its own right and its own set of questions, separate from the building. Left unassessed, it can leak where it was meant to hold water, hold water where it was meant to drain, or slump its own banks.

The pond ground is assessed for the things that actually govern it: whether the native soil is tight enough to act as a liner or whether an engineered clay or synthetic liner is needed; how much seepage to expect and where it goes; and the stability of the embankments and side slopes under rapid filling and rapid drawdown. Where the pond floor sits on compressible soil, settlement is also checked so it will not defeat the design grades. This work hands directly to the separate stormwater and slope-stability pages, which carry the design-report side.

  • Liner adequacy: native soil permeability versus the need for an engineered clay or synthetic liner
  • Seepage: expected losses or inflows, seasonal-high groundwater, and where seepage reports to
  • Stability: embankment and side-slope stability under filling and rapid drawdown, and settlement of the pond floor

Deep foundations: when piles are needed, and why

The single most consequential answer in a commercial report is usually shallow versus deep. Shallow footings or a raft are simpler and cheaper and are the right call whenever competent soil lies at or near founding depth and can carry the loads within settlement tolerance. Piles are the answer when the ground near the surface cannot, and their job is to carry the load down through the weak or variable material to something that can, or to develop capacity along their length in friction.

The trigger is not a preference, it is a soil condition. Weak, soft or highly variable shallow soils; high or concentrated column loads on a small bearing area; deep uncontrolled fill; a high water table; and expansive or soft clays that would swell, shrink or consolidate too much under a spread footing all point toward piles. In Alberta that commonly means bored (cast-in-place) piles or belled piers founded in dense clay till or bedrock, driven piles, or screw (helical) piles for lighter or faster work. The report identifies the founding stratum, its depth and its capacity, and sets out the pile type and length that suit the site. The table below states the trigger plainly.

Ground / load conditionShallow footings or raftDeep foundations (piles / piers)
Competent native soil (firm clay, dense till, sand) at founding depthSuitable, bearing set by settlementNot required
Soft or firm-to-soft clay extending well below footing levelMarginal; settlement usually governsIndicated, carry load to a deeper competent layer
Deep or uncontrolled fill over the building areaNot suitable unless removed and replacedIndicated, drive or bore through fill to native ground
High or concentrated column loads on a small footprintOften exceeds settlement toleranceCommonly required
Expansive (swelling) or soft clay near surfaceHigh risk of movementPiers below the active zone, or piles
High groundwater / seasonally saturated soilsReduced capacity, construction difficultyFrequently indicated
Large footprint over variable soils, tight differential-settlement limitsRisk of uneven settlementPiles even out support across the footprint
When shallow footings work, and when the site is pointing at piles

Coordinating with the structural engineer

A foundation is a shared decision. Andrew Richardson, P.Eng. supplies the ground side: allowable bearing pressures, pile types and capacities, founding depths, settlement estimates and the construction constraints that go with them. The structural engineer supplies the loads and the structure and designs the footings, raft or pile cap to suit. The two have to be reconciled against the real column loads, not placeholders, before anything is finalized.

He writes recommendations to be used that way, in the form the structural engineer needs, and stays available through design and construction to review changes in load or layout, comment on excavations and subgrade, and confirm founding conditions in the field. That field confirmation, checking that what the pile toe or footing actually bears on matches what the report assumed, is where a good investigation earns its keep.

  • Recommendations issued in the form the structural engineer designs from: allowable bearing, pile capacity, founding depth, settlement
  • Reconciled against real column loads, with room to revisit if loads or layout change
  • Available for subgrade review, excavation observation and field confirmation of founding conditions during construction

The standards behind the report

Nothing on a commercial site is decided by house rules. Foundations and excavation requirements come from the National Building Code (2023 Alberta Edition). Bearing capacity, settlement and deep-foundation methods follow the Canadian Foundation Engineering Manual. Field and laboratory work follows the ASTM standards for the standard penetration test, soil classification and consolidation. Public and infrastructure investigations also follow the Geotechnical Investigation Guidelines for Alberta Infrastructure Projects. Excavation safety follows Alberta OHS Code Part 32, and every hole is located through Utility Safety Partners before any drilling starts.

And the report itself is authenticated to APEGA's practice standards: logged, analysed and sealed by a Professional Engineer. The full reference shelf, with a link to every source, lives on the standards page.

When you need it

The situations this answers

  • Multi-unit residential such as townhomes, stacked units, apartments and condominiums, where a single foundation carries many suites
  • Commercial, retail, office, industrial and warehouse buildings with larger footprints and concentrated column or rack loads
  • Any development that includes a stormwater detention or retention pond, an engineered wetland, or underground storm storage
  • Sites on soft, variable or expansive clay, or over deep fill, where settlement (not just bearing failure) governs the design
  • Where a municipality, or the structural engineer, requires a sealed geotechnical report to support the building permit and foundation design
  • Phased or subdivision-scale developments that need a consistent, development-wide picture of the subsurface
  • Where preliminary work, or experience on neighbouring sites, suggests shallow footings may not carry the loads without unacceptable settlement

Need the ground looked at before you build?

Describe what you are building and where. You get a reply, usually within one business day, setting out what the investigation would cover.

Sealed by Andrew Richardson, P.Eng. Serving southern and central Alberta